Waste of lives, waste of money - where's the plan?
Thousands of people have been traumatised and huge amounts of public money have been wasted locking people with a learning disability in mental health hospitals, instead of providing the right support in the community. The government holds the key to stopping this scandal once and for all.
Over 2000 people with a
learning disability
A learning disability is to do with the way someone's brain works. It makes it harder for someone to learn, understand or do things. or autistic people are being held in inpatient mental health hospitals in England.
It’s a
human rights
Human
rights
Rights are the things everyone should be allowed to do like have a say, or go to school. are the rights that everyone has. These include the right to go to school and the right to start a family. scandal that we want to stop.
Many people are locked up because there is a lack of the right
community
A community is the people and places in an area. support, skilled
social care
Social care means the services that give care and support to people who need it., and suitable housing - not because of a mental health problem.
Over the last 12 years,
the government
The Government are the people who run the country. The Government decide how much tax people should pay and how things like the National Health Service (NHS) should work. has promised to reduce the number of people with a learning disability and autistic people in inpatient mental health hospitals.
They have repeatedly missed their own deadlines, and the progress by government, the NHS and local authorities has been far too slow.
Thousands of families have been devastated due to this failure to act – and thousands more will continue to suffer if action isn’t taken urgently.
The latest commitment was to reduce the number of people with a learning disability and autistic people in inpatient units by 50% by March 2024.
The government have missed this target, and we estimate they won’t meet it until 2030 at the earliest.
Elliot’s story
The government promised to reduce the number of people like Elliot held in mental health hospitals by 50%, but they are 6 years off meeting their deadline. The government must urgently come up with a new plan to get more people back in their community with the right support.
People with a learning disability and/or autistic people are locked away in mental health hospitals
Over 6 Years Behind
We estimate the government won't hit their own targets to reduce the number of people held in mental health hospitals until 2030
71% (Nearly three quarters)
of local areas have failed to bring inpatient numbers down to the required level.
4.9 years is the average length of stay for current inpatients
NHS Digital Assuring Transformation data, March 2024 (published April 2024).
What is Mencap calling for?
An updated and strengthened action plan
The government must update and strengthen the Building the Right Support Action plan and targets as a matter of urgency, as the current targets are out of date. In particular, the plan must tackle the ongoing inappropriate detention of people with a learning disability and autistic people and the shocking lengths of stay. It must also address the huge variation in progress between local areas in reducing the number of inpatients with a learning disability and/or autistic people.
The right support in the community
The government published a clear model in 2015 for the support and services that should be in place in all local areas. The government must ensure that local areas develop the right community support- without this the human rights scandal will continue. We need urgent investment in community support, with a real focus on early intervention and prevention. Like anyone else, people with a learning disability and/or autistic people should be able to live life in the community with the right support and suitable housing, close to family and friends.
Reform of the Mental Health Act
People with learning disabilities and/or autistic people should not be inappropriately detained in mental health hospitals. People with a learning disability and autistic people can currently be sectioned under the Mental Health Act even if they don’t have a mental health condition. This is wrong as people can end up detained in a mental health hospital just because there is a lack of the right support in the community, not because they need inpatient mental health care. While detained, they are at increased risk of abuse and neglect in these settings, where there is often a high use of medication and restrictive practices, such as physical, chemical and mechanical restraint and being kept in isolation.
Find out the progress in your local area
The Government target was that by the end of March 2024 there would be no more than 30 adults with a learning disability and/or
autism
Autism is a disability. Autistic people find it difficult to understand what other people think and feel. They also find it difficult to tell people what they think and feel. Everyone with autism is different. in mental health hospitals per million adults who live in a local area. Click on the map to find out if your local area has met the target.
71% of local areas aren’t meeting the required level. This is unacceptable.
We've collected all the data that the government publishes and analysed it to create this resource. Click to find out more about the numbers of adult inpatients in your local area.
could answer a call from someone in crisis who reaches out to our Learning Disability Helpline for support.
£25
could help a trained caseworker stop a parent’s loved one from being wrongfully locked up in a mental health hospital.
£50
could help pay for urgent legal support for a family in desperate need of advice to prevent their loved one being admitted to an in-patient unit.
Campaigning for change
Hear the stories of families whose loved ones were held in mental health inpatient units to understand why things must change.
Tea, smiles and empty promises
Families of some former patients at Winterbourne View came together to mark 10 years since the abuse scandal at the inpatient unit was uncovered, sharing their harrowing stories to highlight continuation of the scandal and the desperate need for change.
Why do people with a learning disability and autistic people end up in these hospitals?
A small number of people with a learning disability may have a mental health problem and benefit from a brief period of
assessment
An assessment is a way of finding out what help a person needs. When you have an assessment, you might have to go to a meeting or fill in a form. and treatment in hospital. However, most people with a learning disability should be able to get the care and support they need in their community. Instead, they are being locked away in hospitals inappropriately due to a lack of community support and end up stuck there for years at a time.
We know that people with a learning disability or autistic people may display ‘distressed’ behaviours, or behaviour that is challenging. These behaviours are a way of communicating their needs. They may be communicating that they are in pain, discomfort, or feeling anxious and frustrated. Sometimes these behaviours may include self-injury, or destructive behaviours.
Without the right support, the person may reach a point of crisis and end up being sent to a mental health hospital even when they don’t have a mental health problem.
For people with a learning disability and autistic people who display behaviour that challenges, the right approach is to provide support in the community. This includes a care package from care staff who have the right skills to support people who may display ‘distressed’ behaviour, a suitable environment (e.g for some people with sensory needs, noise can trigger behaviour), and support from health professionals such as learning disability nurses and psychologists.
Mencap, the
Challenging Behaviour
Challenging behaviour can be when someone hurts themselves, hits or pinches someone else, or breaks something. Some people might behave like this because they are upset or because people do not understand them. Foundation and Respond has published several guides offering advice and support for families, and outlining what good community support looks like: https://www.mencap.org.uk/sites/default/files/2016-08/Meeting%20The%20Challenge%20guide%201.pdf
Is a learning disability and a mental health problem the same thing?
Learning disability is often confused with mental health problems, but they are entirely different. Learning disability is not a mental illness.
Mental health problems can affect anyone at any time, and may be overcome with treatment, which is not true of learning disability.
A learning disability is a reduced intellectual ability which affects someone for their whole life. It means that people might need support with everyday tasks such as shopping, cooking or travelling to new places.
Autism is a lifelong developmental disability which affects how people communicate and interact with the world.
However, people with a learning disability and autistic people may have a mental health problem as well. In these situations, they need the right mental health support like anyone else, and most people should be able to get the support they need in the community.
If a learning disability and autism aren’t the same as mental health problems, then why are people being sectioned?
People with a learning disability and autistic people can currently be sectioned under the Mental Health Act even if they don’t have a mental health problem. We believe this is wrong.
The Government has committed to changing the Mental Health Act and to improve how it works for people with a learning disability and autistic people. They published a Draft Mental Health Bill in 2022 with reforms that would remove the ability for professionals to detain someone purely because of their learning disability, or autism. But we are still waiting for the Mental Health Bill to be brought in and made
law
Laws are the rules that everyone in the country has to follow. If you don't follow the rules you can get in trouble with the police.. The Government is running out of time to do this before the next
election
An election is when people choose who should be in charge of something. This could be in charge of a group, an area, or the country. People choose by voting. The person with the most votes wins.. This is why we are calling on the
Prime Minister
The Prime Minister is the leader of the government. to bring in the Mental Health Bill and make it law as a matter of urgency.
Unfortunately, people can end up being inappropriately sectioned due to a lack of funding and available services in the community. Local authorities and social services have faced many years of
cuts
Cuts are when there is less money to pay for things like clubs and support. and it’s currently estimated there are 165,000 adult social care jobs vacant in England right now.
With the system under pressure and a lack of investment in either the social care workforce or appropriate community housing options, people are frequently becoming ‘stuck’ in these places with no other options.
When will the changes to the Mental Health Act be made?
The Government has committed to changing the Mental Health Act and to improve how it works for people with a learning disability and autistic people.
They published a Draft Mental Health Bill in 2022 with reforms that would remove the ability for professionals to detain someone purely because of their learning disability, or autism.
But we are still waiting for the Mental Health Bill to be brought in and made law. The Government is running out of time to do this before the next election. This is why we are calling on the Prime Minister to bring in the Mental Health Bill and make it law as a matter of urgency.
What is Mencap doing to address this situation?
Mencap is working with a number of families who have loved ones either currently in inpatient units, or who have previously been held in one. The experiences of these families underpin all the campaigning work we do, from raising awareness of the issue to the public, to informing the Government about what needs to be done to make sure people with a learning disability and autistic people get the right support in the community.
We are campaigning with families and other organisations on many fronts, both behind the scenes and publicly, to hold the Government to account and ensure they work together with the NHS and local authorities to provide the right support for people with a learning disability in their local communities, not in institutions.
This includes briefing MPs about the issues and responding to consultations to influence policy and the law, including the Mental Health Act. Last year the government published a new ‘action plan’ to get people with a learning disability and autistic people out of mental health hospitals, and we and many others are working hard to ensure it is strengthened and to influence the plan’s delivery.
We also provide information, advice and legal casework support for people with a learning disability who are in inpatient units and their families.
What is a mental health hospital inpatient unit?
When we refer to “inpatient units” or “mental health hospitals” and “institutions” we are referring to the range of inpatient mental health provision in which people with a learning disability, Autism, or both, may be placed under section. This includes assessment and treatment units (ATUs).
Isabelle, whose son Matthew, was detained in an Assessment and Treatment Unit for 15 months, explains what an inpatient unit is in this video:
What is the Transforming Care programme?
The Transforming Care programme was the government’s response to the public outcry about the shocking abuse taking place at the Winterbourne View
care home
A care home is a place where people who need support live. There are staff there all the time., revealed by BBC’s Panorama in 2011.
After the exposure of Winterbourne View, the government committed to a programme of work aimed at supporting people to move out of units and back to their local communities. The government promised people in inpatient units would be supported to move back to their local communities by 1 June 2014. This simply didn't happen..
In 2015, NHS England has led a 3 year closure programme called ‘Building the right support’. NHS England promised that by May 2019:
35-50% of inpatient beds for people with a learning disability and/or Autism would be closed
the right support would be developed in local communities for people with a learning disability and/or Autism and behaviour that challenges.
NHS England published a 'service model' setting out the range of local support hat should be available in each area by March 2019.
This target was missed and the government promised to close 35% of inpatient beds by March 2020. This was missed as well.
The government has now committed to closing 50% of inpatient beds by March 2024. This target is in the NHS long term plan.
Why can’t families get their loved ones out of these places?
Most people with a learning disability or autistic people who are in mental health hospitals are detained under the Mental Health Act 1983.
At present, it can be too easy for people with a learning disability or autistic people to be sectioned under the Mental Health Act – they don’t even need to have an actual mental health problem – they can be sectioned simply for having ‘distressed’ or ‘challenging’ behaviours. When this happens, it can be very hard for families to challenge the system.
Once people are admitted, they can end up being stuck there for many years as the environment is wrong for their needs and leads to an escalation of ‘distressed’ behaviours. This can make it even harder for them to be allowed to move back into the community, as professionals will argue their behaviour is too challenging. This is a nightmare situation for families, who feel powerless against a system that has their loved one locked away.
The Government has committed to changing the Mental Health Act and to improve how it works for people with a learning disability and autistic people. We hope this step will help to ensure that individuals and families are properly included and listened to. However, the Government is running out of time to do this before the next election. That is why we are calling on the Prime Minister to bring in the Mental Health Bill and make it law as a matter of urgency.
I’m worried about a loved one who has a learning disability, what can I do?
If you have any concerns about the wellbeing of your loved one, please contact Mencap’s Learning Disability Helpline. Our trained advisers can offer support and advice, or signpost to appropriate services who can help.
As every individual case will be different, we want to make sure any advice is relevant to your case. You can visit our
website
A website is a page you can go to on the internet like Google or YouTube. which has lots of information and resources at https://www.mencap.org.uk/contact/contact_mencap_direct or contact our helpline on helpline@mencap.org.uk. You can also call 0808 808 1111 (10am to 3pm, Monday to Friday).
A learning disability is to do with the way someone's brain works. It makes it harder for someone to learn, understand or do things.
or autistic people are being held in inpatient mental health hospitals in England.
Human
rights
Rights are the things everyone should be allowed to do like have a say, or go to school.
are the rights that everyone has. These include the right to go to school and the right to start a family.
scandal that we want to stop.
A community is the people and places in an area.
support, skilled
social care
Social care means the services that give care and support to people who need it.
, and suitable housing - not because of a mental health problem.
The Government are the people who run the country. The Government decide how much tax people should pay and how things like the National Health Service (NHS) should work.
has promised to reduce the number of people with a learning disability and autistic people in inpatient mental health hospitals.
Autism is a disability. Autistic people find it difficult to understand what other people think and feel. They also find it difficult to tell people what they think and feel. Everyone with autism is different.
in mental health hospitals per million adults who live in a local area. Click on the map to find out if your local area has met the target.
