Jump to Navigation
Home
skip navigation
accessibility options
Text size:
-A +A
Contrast:
 High  |  Normal
My Life

Other Mencap sites

Raising Your Game

Helping young people reach their goals.

LiveNet

Developing ICT skills and networks of support.

Little Noise

Acoustic music gigs from Mencap.

Inspire Me

Projects for young people with a learning disability.

Spellathon

Digital spelling competition from Mencap

Mencap jobs

Search and apply online for a job with Mencap

Donate to Mencap

Main menu

  • Home
  • All about learning disability
  • About us
  • What we do
  • Campaigns
  • News
  • Get involved
  • Local groups
  • Donate
  • Community
  • TLD blog

    • Arts
    • Campaigning
    • Family life
    • Get involved
    • News
    • Our View
      • Why can't children with a learning disability fly
    • Social Media

Why shouldn’t I have these things?

Author: Amy Clarke

Posted: 29th Mar 2011

Today I wrote a letter to the editor of The Times about an article they had published called ‘Our immoral pretence at an ordinary life for people like Josie’. It was about people with a learning disability and how much responsibility they should have – particularly with money. As someone with a learning disability this article made me angry.

The article talks about a woman with a learning disability who has got herself into debt by using a credit card. Although I can see that the journalist Minette Marrin understands learning disability (it is amazing how many people don’t!) and has her own personal experiences, she says that ‘Josie and people like her’ shouldn’t be given access to credit cards. Now I think credit cards are a bad idea and I wouldn’t get one – but they are a bad idea for a lot of people without a learning disability too! It is wrong to give the impression that all people with a learning disability are the same and cannot control how much they spend. Everyone is different and everyone can handle different levels of responsibility. I know people who don’t have a learning disability that are terrible with money and just look at where we are with cuts and protests because the government is in debt.

The article also said that it is ‘wishful thinking’ for organisations such as Mencap to want more rights for people with a learning disability and that it is ‘not possible or right for someone with a learning disability to sit on a jury or to be a trustee’. In my letter to the editor I said that it is unfair to say that people with a learning disability can’t have the same opportunities as everyone else. I have my own bank account and look after my own money and I also live in supported living and have a job. And why shouldn’t I have these things? Why shouldn’t I want a job, start a family and be a trustee? Maybe I want to be a trustee, maybe I don’t – I just want the choice like everybody else.

What does everyone else think?

  • Add new comment

Comments

christopher
29 March 2011

I read the article and yes of course people with learning disabilities should have the same rights than everybody else. A person with a learning disability has their own needs that are individual to them and the care system needs to understand this (autism is a good example where the condition isn’t the same for each person which oblivously effects their role in society )Also there are times when a person needs professional help so they are not put into a perious situation. (that;s what protecting people from harm is all about) I’m a trustee and a carer for my dad.

Sonia
29 March 2011

I agree with everything you’ve said. People with learning disabilities should have the same rights as every other person. If someone doesn’t have the capacity to do something that’s one thing but we shouldn’t assume that just because some has a learning disability that they don’t have the capacity to do certain things. I hope the times listen to you and apologise.

Casdok
29 March 2011

Yes why shouldnt you – and anything is possible. You should have exactly the same rights and the same choices. You also have the right to make mistakes.
Its this narrow minded attitude is exactly why we need organisations like Mencap to educate people and raise awareness.
Well said Amy.

kaypomors
19 March 2013

swiss rolex

Knowledge
You should drive your member of the team toward his or her next phase. Enable your crew have in mind the achievement of everyone. After somebody achieve his or her own next stage. Declare the idea for your team. This may
6 Important elements for you to Leadership
Travel your current staff towards quality. Make sure your own staff comprehend the diverse levels inside your company. Gemstone degree, party chief stage, representative level, presidential level. whichever your business the idea.
Levels of competition

swiss watches store

Useful links

  • Contact us
  • Jobs
  • Wales
  • Northern Ireland
  • Media centre
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy and Cookie policy
  • Site map
Local groups online

Mencap on Twitter

  • mencap_charity
    mencap_charity 'My boys squabble just the same as any siblings'. Read Caroline's @carolineplayle full blog 'Sibling chivalry' at: t.co/EHugMBcpPH
    15 hours 22 min ago.
  • mencap_charity
    mencap_charity RT @RobHoll: Lord Rix @mencap_charity President speaking NOW on the importance fo social care for people wth a learning disability t…
    17 hours 9 min ago.
  • mencap_charity
    mencap_charity NHS still not serving all patients with learning disabilities well, says Ombudsman. Full report: t.co/ymoq2Ms6r4 #DeathbyIndifference
    19 hours 3 min ago.

follow Mencap on Twitter

Mencap on Facebook

Become a fan of Mencap!

Mencap on Flickr

See all our photos

 

Mencap Direct

0808 808 1111

Lines open 9am to 5pm, Monday to Friday

Donate

Make a real and lasting difference

 

Charity number 222377 (England, Northern Ireland and Wales); SCO41079 (Scotland)